NSW's price advertising backflip: confusion for agents and buyers alike

By
Jared Zak
17 November 2026
Stay informed monthly

Agents spent months preparing for tough new price advertising rules in NSW. Then, the evening before they were due to start, the Premier pulled the handbrake.

On Monday 16 November 2026, Premier Chris Minns shelved the next stage of the Government's underquoting reforms, which were set to take effect on Tuesday 17 November. The rules are expected to be paused for up to a year while the Government reassesses the whole package (ABC News).

For agents who had already updated their listing templates, trained staff and briefed vendors, it is a frustrating reversal. For buyers, who were promised clearer and more honest price guides, it raises a simple question: what rules actually apply now?

What has been put on hold

Three key elements of the reforms are now on ice, according to the ABC report:

  • The "rejected offer" floor. Agents would have been barred from advertising a price lower than a written offer the seller had already rejected.
  • Mandatory price guides. Agents would have been required to advertise a selling price or price range for properties.
  • Tougher penalties. Fines of up to $110,000 for underquoting have also been deferred.

With only a few sitting days of Parliament left this year, the Government is not expected to amend the legislation. Instead, it is expected to make a regulation to delay commencement. Until that regulation is published, the precise legal mechanics of the pause remain unclear.

Importantly, underquoting itself is not suddenly legal. Advertising a property below the price an agent expects it to sell for is already prohibited in NSW, and those existing obligations continue to apply.

How we got here: from flagship reform to last-minute U-turn

These were not obscure rules. They were a centrepiece of the Government's housing agenda, consulted on for months, passed by Parliament and widely publicised to the industry.

Date Milestone
16 Nov 2026 Premier pauses the reforms the day before commencement, citing the falling market (ABC News)
Jan to Nov 2026 Sydney house prices fall close to 9.7%, and units 5.2%, according to Cotality data cited by the ABC
24 Jun 2026 Parliament passes the Property and Stock Agents Amendment (Underquoting and Other Agent Conduct) Bill 2026, with a 17 November start date
13 Nov 2025 Government releases the reform package for consultation, including the rejected-offer floor
2015 NSW first legislates a specific underquoting prohibition, tying advertised prices to the agent's estimated selling price

‍

NSW first legislates a specific underquoting prohibition, tying advertised prices to the agent's estimated selling price

The Bill lifted underquoting penalties from $22,000 to $110,000, or three times the agent's commission if greater. It also gave NSW Fair Trading power to obtain independent valuations and to require agents to publicly disclose breaches (LSJ).

The Premier now describes the downturn problem as "unforeseen". The industry disagrees. The Real Estate Institute of NSW says it warned the Government the rejected-offer rule would not work in practice and was ignored. Agents were raising the same concern in the press only days before commencement (Newcastle Herald).

Agents: prepared for one regime, now working under another

The industry was told to get ready, and many did. Agencies rebuilt pricing workflows around comparable sales, reworked agency agreement templates and briefed vendors that "contact agent" listings were on the way out. NSW Fair Trading issued new underquoting guidelines on 12 November, just days before the pause (EDUTIVE).

The result is a patchwork, and agents now need to work out which layer they are standing on.

Still in force. The first stage of the 2026 reforms has applied since 29 June 2026. It brought higher maximum penalties for a range of existing offences and new disciplinary powers for Fair Trading, including requiring agents to publicise their misconduct and to have an estimated selling price independently verified (EDUTIVE). Nothing reported so far suggests these are being wound back.

Still the law. The long-standing estimated selling price regime continues. Agents must record a reasonable estimate in the agency agreement, revise it in writing when evidence shows it is no longer reasonable, and never quote or advertise below it (NSW Fair Trading).

On hold. Mandatory price guides, the rejected-offer floor and the $110,000 underquoting penalty.

Unclear. Whether the pause also captures the new comparable sales method, the record-keeping rules and the Statement of Information scheduled for February 2027. The ABC reports the Government is reassessing the "full suite" of changes, but until the regulation is made and Fair Trading updates its guidance, agents are left to read the tea leaves.

There is also an irony here. A rule meant to stop agents misleading buyers was paused because, in a falling market, it could have forced agents to advertise prices that no longer reflected reality. As REINSW put it, buyers would not learn that a property had become more affordable.

Buyers and sellers: mixed messages in a falling market

For buyers, the promised end of "contact agent" listings has been postponed. Buyers were told every listing would carry a price or range. Some had started planning their search on that basis and are now disappointed (Yahoo News). Expect to see priceless listings for a while yet, and do not assume a missing price means a property is out of reach.

Buyers still have protection. An agent cannot quote or advertise below the estimated selling price in the agency agreement. Complaints can be made to NSW Fair Trading on 13 32 20 (NSW Fair Trading).

For sellers, the pause removes a real risk in this market. Under the paused rule, a vendor who knocked back a written offer of $1.3 million while holding out for $1.5 million could never advertise below $1.3 million, even if the market moved against them (ABC News). That flexibility is back, at least for now.

But sellers should not mistake a pause for a repeal. A revised version may return within 12 months. Decisions made now, such as how offers are documented and why they are rejected, could matter if the rules commence later in a modified form.

What to do now

Until the Government publishes its regulation and Fair Trading updates its guidance, we suggest the following.

  • Agents: keep complying with the existing estimated selling price rules, and keep the comparable sales evidence behind every estimate. Good records are your best defence under any version of the law.
  • Agents: do not unwind new templates and systems in a hurry. Some or all of the reforms may return within a year.
  • Sellers: document written offers and your reasons for rejecting them. Ask your agent how the estimated selling price was set and when it will be reviewed.
  • Buyers: ask agents for the price range directly, check recent comparable sales, and report suspected underquoting to Fair Trading.
  • Everyone: watch for the regulation formalising the pause, and for any revised reform package in 2027.

Dott & Crossitt will continue to monitor this space and update clients as the position becomes clearer. If you are buying or selling, or you run an agency and want to check your compliance position, contact our property team.

This article is general information only and current as at 17 November 2026. It is not legal advice. The position may change quickly once the Government makes its regulation. You should obtain advice about your specific circumstances.

Sources

More Insights

Gold Coast

What is a leasehold property?

Real Life Grave Robbers

What Is a Strata Committee? A Guide for NSW Strata Buyers

Jared Zak, founder of Dott & Crossitt

A trust account is an obligation, not a profit centre